|
|
 |
| Searching laws and regulations (the complete
'code') is easy and the results can be replicated by anyone. And,
the results are the same for everyone.
Much of this page applies to downloading your own copy of the
official tax regulations, 26 CFR, from the GPO, and searching
with your own computer.
If you want to search immediately, or you want to use the government
search engines, without having to compile your own copy, then
these will work
- eCFR for regulations.
Read this.
- The CFR-Repaired Edition, PDF file (not
boolean
searchable)
- GPO, and third party code search engines, for statutes. See
According
to Law.
|
|
The Government Printing Office does not make downloading
a complete digital copy of the regulations easy. If you prefer to skip
the laborious task of compiling your copy, you can get a copy with the
repair work already done for you. See Tax
Regs 1913-2004.
If you trust no one, congratulations (we agree).
Instructions are provided below to compile your own CFR copy.
Need help searching? Contact Us.
Note: This simple search technique can be applied
to all Titles of Law, Regulations, or any large volume of text.
However, only codes are precise; large volumes of text are not.
Common tools that you can use to search downloadable Titles of Code,
or Regulations:
- Computer - we used Windows 2000 OS - XP and Vista are
fine. Linux is the best option, but only Windows is explained here.
- High Speed Internet connection - recommended.
- HTTrack Website Copier - free Open Source offline browser
for Linux and Windows.
- WinMerge - free Open Source tool required on some searches
for file and directory comparison. Other similar tools are fine.
- Adobe Acrobat - tool used to search PDF files. (Optional
tool)
- eCFR - a GPO website that has an excellent regulation
search tool.
- Code search engines - third-party or government engines.
See our According to Law link.
Other search tools are available, such as website search engine programs
for your PC. We recommend using only open source programs for this task.
You can try: mnoGoSearch or DataparkSearch. Search Google or Clusty
for others. The times are always changing, and so is software.
For now, stick with the following method, which shows the required
tasks and results using basic fundamentals of text data mining. Later,
you can trust other search tools, and maximize their usefulness.
We highly recommend beginning in your local law library with
a tour from the reference librarian.
[The CFR is downloaded 'as is' (approx. 66MB for TEXT - [zip file
20MB], or 26~31MB for PDF) from the US Government Printing Office (GPO)
Website. A complete mirror is approx. 346 MB with both PDF and TEXT
files (we don't serve that). Size varies slightly each year. The single
PDF file version is the easiest to search for most
people, but a more powerful search can be made using the TEXT version.
For computers, Windows will do fine, but Linux has the most capabilities.]
USC (the law):
[Note: This section has been moved. See According
to Law and Who
is Taxed.]
To search the Text files or PDF files, simply use EDIT > FIND on the
menu, or CTRL + F. Always begin your searches with the cursor placed
at the beginning of the file (use CTRL + HOME, and even click into the
beginning of the text).
CFR (the regulations):
How to Search TEXT version: (Provides for faster searching, but requires
some set-up)
Quick How to Search TEXT:
- Download this TEXT copy of the US
Income Tax Regulations. Why this one? Because it is compressed
to 20MB and downloads faster, and all the broken links and missing
files from the GPO original version are fixed. A big time saver.
(Since you will eventually want to verify our copy with the
original, instructions to compile your own copy from the GPO
are provided below. You can also compare accuracy with the eCFR.
Note, the eCFR will refer to its search results as 'matches')
- Open the folder where you placed your copy, then open Main
Folder and click Search.
- Search for any subject. Use one term or more. Example: "taxable"
or "taxable income". See image
below.
|
|
How to Compile your own copy:
We used a free tool, WinHTTrack Website Copier, to download the entire
Title 26 CFR (regulations), and USC (laws) to a local computer. Searching
for a particular term is done from the folder containing Title 26. In
general, here is how to setup and search...
- Download and install the tool WinHTTrack
Website Copier (open source and free). Be sure to get WinHTTrack
for Windows. They also provide a Linux version. Learn to use on a
small (few pages) website. Many similar tools are available to download
a website; find and choose your favorite. Practice by downloading
this website. Be sure you begin the download process on the page that
you would like for the "home" page. For this website, that would be
http://whatistaxed.com/index.htm. Practice on a small size website,
before you accidentally fill up your entire computer hard drive with
every Title of the laws and regulations.
- Using a "high speed" internet connection, and WinHTTrack Website
Copier, download the latest CFR and USC from the GPO website. (WinHTTrack
has an option setting for the web addresses that it must search. Pay
attention to the web addresses in case any of your downloaded pages
are missing. Also find and chose the option to ignore robots.txt file.)
From the addresses below, choose Title 26 and the year desired. The
resulting CFR webpage will have Sections 1 thru End, and Parts 2 thru
End. Beginning here will produce an approx. 346MB CFR download. The
size of the download can be decreased considerably to a 66MB size
by setting WinHTTrack to exclude all the PDF files, which are duplicates
of the HTML files. Search the WinHTTrack Help for help.
The USC is also available in a 24MB MSWord doc.
USC: http://www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode/index.html
or http://uscode.house.gov/
CFR: http://www.gpoaccess.gov/cfr/index.html
Allow up to 4 - 8 hours, or more, for complete download, ~346MB of
PDF and TEXT on High Speed internet connection, depending on your
speed. Grabbing the TEXT files only, goes much faster. Unknown time
for dialup. The HTTrack Website Copier has an excellent resume download
function, so it can be downloaded in multiple sessions, but we don't
recommend it. Because the government servers are serving 'fresh' files,
the Website Copier will update the files, according to time, thus
producing another long download that will again require repair.
If you must use a dialup connection, download one of our copies
of tax regulations. PDF ~26.4MB, TEXT ~20.1MB
The PDF is Part 1-Income Taxes, and the TEXT is all Parts of Title
26.
After the download is complete, check for missing files/ broken
links. This is required only if compiling your own copy from the
GPO. (See http://whatistaxed.servehttp.com
for more info.) We recommend setting the permissions for the folder
where you put your copy to read only. How? Right-click on the folder
> properties > check Read-only. This is to prevent accidentally
deleting any of the Regulations while performing the search process.
If you choose not to set these permissions, check your Recycle Bin
often for any files from the CFR directory that may need restoring.
This will be evident when a familiar term is not repeating previous
results. * Do not restore any files from your "Compare" folders,
discussed in #4 below. Make a backup copy of your original because
it's easy to spoil your active copy.
-
CFR : How to Search with Computer -
Image. Done with Win 2000. Should be similar with 95, 98, ME, XP
and Vista.
A. Open the folder where you saved your copy of CFR.
B. Click on search.
C. Put search term into "Containing Text:" search box, or similar.
D. Click Search Now button, but be certain the correct folder is
displayed in "Look in:"
E. Open result(s) in any web browser (eg Firefox, Internet Explorer,
etc).
F. In web browser, use Edit > Find, or Ctrl+F to search for term.

For example, if we search for "how to determine taxable income",
search results will show (1 file(s) found) in the lower left window.
Search for:
"excluded income"
"eliminated income"
"eliminated items"
Be aware that since you are searching through HTML files, a line
break can disrupt attempts to search the terms that are spread over
2 lines of text. For example, if "determine" is on the end of a
line, and "taxable" begins on the next line, the full string of
text will not be found in the Windows folder search. So, in order
to verify any particular result, each keyword must be independently
searched, then merged.
-
Merging example using "how to determine taxable income":
First, we find the individual results...
- "determine": (2748 file(s) found)
- "taxable income": (817 file(s) found)
- "how to": (38 file(s) found)
Then we merge results, effectively making a boolean search of the
regulations. See No. 6 below for how to merge. The order of the
terms used is not critical, the final result is the same.
*Note: The eCFR permits a three term boolean search,
however you can use unlimited terms in your boolean searches using
your computer and a directory comparison tool, such as WinMerge.
If all this seems like a pain in the neck (and it was, to figure
out), just use the eCFR
for searching regulations, and GPO
Access for searching the statutes. The best part about these
government websites is that you are getting your results straight
from the horses mouth (their own search engines).
(These numbers are for year 2004 regulations. Numbers change slightly
every year due to new text added to each new edition, or due to
editing changes, by the GPO. Again, for example, "taxable income"
may no longer show up in the basic search if "taxable"
is the last word on a line and "income" is on the next
line. Compare your results with a PDF version of 26 CFR, and the
eCFR, to avoid this effect.)
"taxable income" and "determine":
(614 object(s))
"taxable income" and "determine"
and "how to": (7 object(s))
Can you believe it? Only seven sections have all the terms, leaving
little room for uncertainty.
Since some files could still be missing from these results, double
check by altering the combined terms, e.g. using "determine
taxable" instead of "taxable income". Soon all files
are found.
- Objects
From these 7 files/objects, we then search
each one individually for "how to determine taxable income",
or use only one of the keywords, such as "taxable" or "how
to". To do so, open the file in your web browser, then use
CTRL + F, or the Edit menu, to find text.
All this has been done to confirm that
the text string "how to determine taxable income",
or anything like it, only occurs once, or in only one regulation.
More details for merging are provided next.
|
|
- How to Merge:
When WinMerge is required
to refine CFR searches - the basic instructions for use of this tool
are:
- Copy the contents of one of your "partial term" searches from
the Search folder to a folder you create, maybe somewhere on your
'desktop', called Compare1. For example: "how to " (notice space
before the end quote)
- Copy the contents of another "partial term" search, like "taxable
income", into a second folder called Compare2.
- Start WinMerge and compare the 2 folders (directories).
- Click on the "Comparison Result" column top box. This will
sort the results. Be sure to keep all "Identical" results.
- With the "Identical" results now sorted to the top of the list,
scroll down till you see the others. Highlight all the others
(all non-identical results) by selecting the first non-identical
result, then using Shift+End, then right-click and delete both
parts which mention 'delete'. It must be done twice, to delete
both sets of 'deletes'.
You are now left with only the files containing identical results,
both "partial terms" (e.g. all files containing the terms "how to
" and "taxable income") in both Compare1 and Compare2 folders. Open
the Compare1 folder to see the results.
Open the results with your internet browser to read each. If you
need to further refine your search, for example, in order to find
all files that also include "apply", then delete only the contents
of Compare2 folder and repeat the whole process from step 2. Search
for "apply", and then copy the results to the Compare2 folder. Re-compare
both folder 1 and 2 using WinMerge, and delete all non-identical
results. In the end you will have only the files with all 3 search
terms; "how to ", "taxable income", and "apply".
You can keep on refining searches repeatedly for more terms, until
finally it is possible you may only have 1 remaining file with all
the desired terms. This search method is how you can prove exclusive
search term results.
For example:
"specific","guidance","rules","taxable","income","apply","how to","taxable
income" (1 file(s) found): Sec. 861
When you have become proficient, you can create a 3rd folder or
more. Only two folders are required.
See Search Examples
for hints to searching.
If you use a computer with Linux, then the entire searching process
is greatly simplified. Powerful search tools are already available within
a Linux operating system. Learn how to use them by searching the Internet
for tutorials.
PDF version - 26 CFR:
How to Download and Search a PDF version:
Download PDF file from http://whatistaxed.com/26CFR.htm
Download Adobe Reader (or Acrobat) if needed from Adobe.com > Open PDF
file > Click Search > enter search term(s) > Click Search
Here are some terms you can search for: Search
Results, Additional
Results, Search
Examples
If you want to compile your own PDF copy
Since you shouldn't trust just anyone on the Internet, you can compile
your own copy. The individual volumes (and parts of volumes) can be
obtained in PDF files from the GPO website, and compiled using the following
method:
1. Select desired year of Title 26 CFR
.
2. Once inside the particular year, under "Search Title" column,
remove checkmark from Title 26 Internal Revenue.
3. Place a checkmark under the desired "Search Volume" column
(get all of Part 1 [volumes 1-13 for 2003/2004]).
4. In Search Terms box, type: part 1 income taxes
5. Click Submit
6. Usually choose the 3rd result, but look for result with [a] the largest
size, and [b] the table of contents.
7. Examine Volume to see if it's complete.
8. Download missing sections if needed until the particular volume is
complete. Do it for all volumes.
9. (Optional) If available, use Adobe Acrobat (the writer version) to
combine files into one large PDF file.
Or, just get the CFR in PDF files here: http://whatistaxed.com/26CFR.htm
If you can provide a regulation or statute, which indicates the search
results, analysis, or findings are not accurate ... send it us.
|
|
|
|
Attention Researchers
If any link has disappeared, try to copy and
paste the link address at http://www.archive.org
-- DISCLAIMER --
* The intended purpose of this website is
to data mine on a computer the Internal Revenue Code, and the
Code of Federal Regulations, Title 26, for the "codes" (e.g.
taxable income, gross income, excluded income, eliminated income,
exempt income, deductions, allocation, apportionment, etc),
for rules, and instructions, for determining income tax. The
results have been published throughout this website. It should
be evident that these search methods can be applied to any Title
of Law, or large volume of text, and in any country that
has codified laws and rules. See How to Search.
There is nothing for sale at WhatisTaxed.com.
Information posted at WhatisTaxed.com is not intended to be
and should not be considered as legal advice, it is posted solely
for educational purposes. The reader should not rely on information
provided herein to determine tax, even if you see that it is
written in the law, and believe it to be accurate. (Those who
go against, or simply question, the US government, even if those
who are questioning are, or were, themselves government agents
or employees, regardless of their beliefs, risk
prison time, a bad
reputation, or worse.
Those who speak truth to power have always paid heavily for
doing so.)
Do Not accept this website as tax advice, it is tax research
and copyright-free (copyleft
whatistaxed.com). To contribute research, see How to Search and
Contact Us.
We Do Not sell, promote, or advise anything,
except the data-mining and reading of tax code with an appropriate
code-tool, a computer.
We Do ensure that we find every occurrence of
a particular code-term, to establish precisely what is written,
and what is not written in the law. When we say no
other rule or statutes exists - for example, regarding excluded
income, we show you how many files contain this term and
how we searched for it with a computer. You can confirm ANY
of the laws, rules, and terms yourself, and you should because
it is your duty to know and follow the law.
You are
responsible for doing your own taxes.
Questions: If you have questions, try asking
your Congressperson or Senator.
Have your lawmaker explain these search results ...
- "eliminated income" - Sec. 1.861-8(d), 1.861-8(d)(2),
1.861-8T(d)(2)
- "eliminated items" - Sec. 1.861-8T(d)
- "excluded income" - Sec. 1.861-8 and 1.861-8T
- "income that is exempt or excluded" - Sec. 1.861-8T(d)(2)
- "specific sources" - Sec. 1.861-8(a)(1)
- "specific guidance" - Sec. 1.861-8(a)(1)
- "how to determine taxable income" - Sec. 1.861-8(a)(1)
- "the rules [of Sec. 1.861-8 ...] for determining taxable
income" - Sec. 1.863-1(c)
- "income that is not considered tax exempt" [taxable
income] - Sec. 1.861-8T(d)(2)(iii)
Have them explain ...
- Why are such specific instructions, which are located almost
exclusively in Sec. 861, frivolous?
- If lawmakers are going to give the Treasury Secretary
power ("under regulations prescribed by the Secretary"
- 26 USC 863), to create laws for items of income
and deductions, then why is most of the CFR code valid, but
not Sec. 861 code?
- What other definition of "exempt income" is there?
According to code, there is only one, defined in Sec. 1.861-8T(d)(2)(ii).
And, it's followed immediately by the list of income that
is not exempt (i.e. taxable).
Find your Congressperson: http://www.house.gov
Find your Senator: http://www.senate.gov
Answers: If you want answers, you can try
asking the press, the American
media and foreign
media.
* TheCode of Federal Regulations:
When searching, we pay close attention to the rules in 26 CFR,
because the law (USC) gives authority to the CFR (regulations).
Both the USC and CFR confirm this authority [easily find this
authorization with your computer].
"the Federal Income Tax Regulations
(Regs) are the official Treasury Department interpretation of
the Internal Revenue Code" (Internal Revenue Manual,
4.10.7.2.3.1).
The Code of Federal Regulations are the rules, written in plain
English, which both the public and the IRS must follow:
"The Service is bound by the
regulations." (Internal Revenue Manual, 4.10.7.2.3.4).
Since "the Service is bound," we can be sure that
we are playing by the same rules. It does not require a law
degree to understand them. See How to Search and Search Examples.
© Many other logos and images used here are
protected by copyright and/or trademark. We believe their use
qualifies as fair
use under United States copyright law.
|
|
Reforming or re-hiding?
"Fear can only prevail when victims are ignorant of the facts."
-- Thomas Jefferson